Michelangelo Pizzeria & Restaurant in Eastport

Ordered pizza through the slice application and specifically asked for our pizza to be well done yet it shows up luke warm and well under poked instead. Quite upsetting and probably should have listened to others about this place not having the best of pizza for it was not only undercooked but had very little taste. The wings we ordered were okay. A little small but for the price it’s expected. The flavor of the mild sauce wasn’t terrible but could have been better. Do better and focus more on your pizza. Will not be ordering again. I also see comments from owners of whoever is auditing your reviews saying it’s a rare occurrence and doesn’t really happen but there are many other reviews similar to mine.

We ordered spaghetti and meatballs and buffalo wings(hot). I’ve had better spaghetti and meatballs from Dennys or Country Pride. The sauce sucked and the meat balls were gross (mealy feeling) with no substance or flavor. The wings were cooked well but had no flavor either and we’re certainly not hot.

I love this pizzeria. Family owned , hard working people. I ordered Alfredo sauce pizza with broccoli. It was the most delicious pizza, the dough was so incredibly good and it wasn't soaked and the thickness of it was perfect. All I can say is MMMMM!

Pizza and calzone was great! Service was also great!

The cheesesteak itself tasted good but there was such little meat that I thought I was just eating bread.

Wow..... grandma pie is the best pizza ever, reminds me of old school Brooklyn..... doesn't get any better

Great pizza and salads. Order for my family and staff from here all the time.

Great service and great food! My children love their pizza and it’s the only place we order dinner from when I don’t want to cook. 😁 No complaints!

Great tasting food, but i feel as though im enjoying mostly bread due to how they made my shrimp parm. Would not recommend the shrimp parm unless you want to be dry eating your "meal".

New jersey pizza. Try the thin crust. Very good

Pizza is always AWESOME!! VERY FRIENDLY PEOPLE.

It typically looks closed from the outside but I Absolutely love this place ! My family and I have been ordering from Michaelangelo’s for many years and I can honestly say I’m never disappointed. I live within walking distance to Mancini’s pizza and choose this place over them in a heartbeat. I love everything I’ve ever ordered but my favorites are the chicken roll which is big enough to share, the shrimp parmigiana or meatball sandwich! when they say 30-40 mins for delivery they mean it ! Just placed an order at 6:07 for a chicken Cesar salad and by 6:35 the delivery man was ringing my doorbell. Can’t beat the service & quality.

we ordered food to be delivered and they got our order wrong even though they repeated it back correctly. We called back and they wanted to charge us for their mistake. I will never order from here again. Their food is good but I can find that elsewhere. Customer service is lacking majorly.

Awesome food. The owner is a real Gentelman who strives for perfection! My new go to spot for all things Italian and Pizza in East Brunswick area. They also deliver quickly which is a huge plus.

Excellent service and always friendly and welcoming. The pizzas are terrific as are the sandwiches and calzones we have ordered. The best thing crust in town!

The staff is always very kind and considerate. Their food is on point. Prices are average. And portions are good. This is one of our go to spots because they are so nice and deliver too.

Great food, quick service

Seems like your average pizza place when walking in, but after ordering and sitting down to take a bite I realized that this is more then just average. I had the spinach & ricotta as well as a buffalo chicken. They both were very good and cooked just right and had a lot of toppings.

Delicious pizza! Friendly staff.

No complaints 👌🏽

Great food, awesome customer service

Best pizza I've had in a very long time.

Great Pizza and great service. a bit expensive compared to the big chains but totally worth it! real pizza and great flavor!

Great pizza! The buffalo wings were fantastic! Great and friendly service!!!

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had!! This is always my first choice. Pick up, delivery and dine in. I’ve always had such a pleasant experience and amazing food!! Tonight’s choice was buffalo chicken pizza. I honestly don’t think I’ve ever had it better anywhere else!!

Very good pizza at a hidden corner.

Good food, fast service

Pizza deal was great! Staff was friendly and welcoming :)

Food and service is always excellent! Our go-to place to order in from. Delicious!!

Excellent food, very nice people, plenty area for Park. Affordable price

Friendly service, good food

Awesome food and service so happy I called them I’m new to the area. It’s was great!

One of the best wings I have had yet

Best pizza. Fresh food. Delicious. Very friendly staff and great service!

The cooking good food to eat

I love this place. Everything was amazing, delicious, full of flavor and fresh.

Large portions of hot reasonably priced subpar food. It's just not that good. Nice service.

Pizza is great... but order it far In advance. 90 minutes to deliver two pies 4 minutes down the road is excessive.

Use to work near there and always have great pizza sandwiches and salads

Best thin crust pizza in the area. Make sure you ask for thin crust!

We drop by this place on our way home to Virginia every time we visit New York City.The location isn't all that convenient, but pizza is made by the folks with pride and it is delicious!

Great thin crust pizza! Highly recommend

Pizza is very bland, crust is not crisp and a thick sheet of cheese with very little sauce. The people are very nice! If you go don't expect much. I tried this place again as I pass by often. Had a sandwich and it was worst then the pizza. I don't like giving a poor review but I read the reviews to avoid bad food, I would not recommend. I can't imagine how this place has a high rating it does not deserve. 2 stars for nice people and service.

Great food...friendly staff.

Excellent pizza and food. Great prices. They also make a thin crust pizza upon request and it's superb!

Only gave 5 stars because 1000000 wasn't available. Pizza is the best in NJ, and the owner is just a hilariously wonderful guy with a great sense of humor. I'm a pizza critic, and I love this place. Huge slices, great food, and very reasonable prices. See you tomorrow for MORE PIZZAAAAA!!!

Pizza slices are huge and sooo delicious. Employees are clearly very hard working and care about their customers. Great food and even better service. Also the price is very low for the very good quality of food. Definitely stop by! If I am in town again I will definitely stop in!

Solid pizza... Reasonable prices.., friendly owners.... As good as Central Jersey pizza gets. Give them a shot... You won't be disappointed

Home Italian restaurant with family favorites. I'll come back anytime.